(no subject)
Jul. 15th, 2009 01:58 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
brokenrecordWent to the midnight showing of Harry Potter last night with some friends!
The critic (and some fan) reviews about how this is the best movie of the series yet, or at least since PoA baffle me because I was not a huge fan of this. Well, PoA was my least favorite of the movies before this, so I guess my opinion isn't typical. But I don't know, I thought OotP was loads better than this one; I was incredibly impressed after seeing that one after having pretty low expectations for it.
My issues weren't with stuff being left out, either (although SERIOUSLY COME ON YOU COULD HAVE INCLUDED DUMBLEDORE'S FUNERAL) but just... how anticlimactic everything seemed? Even Dumbledore's death was just kind of "Huh, okay." I mean, the kiss with Ginny was just kind of "Well, that happened and now isn't going to be addressed again." The Death Eaters storming Hogwarts was pretty pathetic. They just killed Dumbledore (which wasn't even them anyways, it was all Snape, so they didn't even have to be there for that) and made some windows shatter and stomped on the tables in the Grand Hall (or Great Hall? I don't remember. Whatever it is) and then they were like "Well, that was fun." I agree with whichever of my friends said after the movie that it was much more effective in the book when Harry and Dumbledore come back and there's the mark in the sky and you just kind of feel the impending doom. And Dumbledore's Army was supposed to reunite! I mean, where were Hermione and Ron during all of this, even? Similarly, the Half Blood Prince reveal was pretty lame. There wasn't the same sort of build-up, and the way Snape was just like "Hey, btw, I was the Half-Blood Prince. Later!" was just like "...uh, ok?"
My least favorite thing was the last scene, though, if only for when Hermione is basically just like "Well, Dumbledore died. That sucked. So, anyways, Ron's totally cool with you and Ginny!" Just... worst segue EVER.
Also, I try not to complain about them leaving out stuff from the books because I realize the books are ginormous and the movie was already 2 1/2 hours long, but I was really sad that they left out Dumbledore arriving at the Dursleys in the beginning of the book because I remember I was totally cracking up throughout that entire part. Especially since what they included instead (random girl asking out Harry Potter) was... kind of bizarre.
I actually did enjoy the movie! It wasn't as good as I hoped, but I guess the book isn't anywhere near my favorite (probably 5th, but my opinions on all the books waver, so it's also been as far down as 7th) maybe I shouldn't have expected to like it as much as OotP? I don't know. But loads of the scenes were really beautiful, and the movie was a lot funnier than I expected (although often unintentionally so; pretty much every scene with Draco cracked me up, and I don't really know why. He was just kind of skulking all over the castle all angsty and I don't know, it was just really amusing). The part where Harry is on the Felix whatever was absolutely hilarious. I'm glad I saw the movie, in any case.
I'm so sleepy now. I got home around 3:30 AM but I had had a coffee and waaaayyyy too much candy before/during the movie, so it took me until past 4 AM to fall asleep, and then my mom decided it'd be a good idea to wake me up at 9 AM. And after I've woken up I can't get back to sleep again, and I can't take naps during the day or else I can't sleep at night, so I'm pretty much just a zombie right now.
I'm surprised at the lack of Harry Potter enthusiasm on my flist! For some reason I remember there being loads when OotP came out. Was that just because people typically like Ootp more than HBP? Or because the last book was coming out right after the movie so people were all amped up about that, but now that the series is over people don't care as much?
Anyways, I think I might reread the series now. The last time I did a read-through was right before DH came out, and I've only read that one once (and HBP only twice), so it seems like it's time.
The critic (and some fan) reviews about how this is the best movie of the series yet, or at least since PoA baffle me because I was not a huge fan of this. Well, PoA was my least favorite of the movies before this, so I guess my opinion isn't typical. But I don't know, I thought OotP was loads better than this one; I was incredibly impressed after seeing that one after having pretty low expectations for it.
My issues weren't with stuff being left out, either (although SERIOUSLY COME ON YOU COULD HAVE INCLUDED DUMBLEDORE'S FUNERAL) but just... how anticlimactic everything seemed? Even Dumbledore's death was just kind of "Huh, okay." I mean, the kiss with Ginny was just kind of "Well, that happened and now isn't going to be addressed again." The Death Eaters storming Hogwarts was pretty pathetic. They just killed Dumbledore (which wasn't even them anyways, it was all Snape, so they didn't even have to be there for that) and made some windows shatter and stomped on the tables in the Grand Hall (or Great Hall? I don't remember. Whatever it is) and then they were like "Well, that was fun." I agree with whichever of my friends said after the movie that it was much more effective in the book when Harry and Dumbledore come back and there's the mark in the sky and you just kind of feel the impending doom. And Dumbledore's Army was supposed to reunite! I mean, where were Hermione and Ron during all of this, even? Similarly, the Half Blood Prince reveal was pretty lame. There wasn't the same sort of build-up, and the way Snape was just like "Hey, btw, I was the Half-Blood Prince. Later!" was just like "...uh, ok?"
My least favorite thing was the last scene, though, if only for when Hermione is basically just like "Well, Dumbledore died. That sucked. So, anyways, Ron's totally cool with you and Ginny!" Just... worst segue EVER.
Also, I try not to complain about them leaving out stuff from the books because I realize the books are ginormous and the movie was already 2 1/2 hours long, but I was really sad that they left out Dumbledore arriving at the Dursleys in the beginning of the book because I remember I was totally cracking up throughout that entire part. Especially since what they included instead (random girl asking out Harry Potter) was... kind of bizarre.
I actually did enjoy the movie! It wasn't as good as I hoped, but I guess the book isn't anywhere near my favorite (probably 5th, but my opinions on all the books waver, so it's also been as far down as 7th) maybe I shouldn't have expected to like it as much as OotP? I don't know. But loads of the scenes were really beautiful, and the movie was a lot funnier than I expected (although often unintentionally so; pretty much every scene with Draco cracked me up, and I don't really know why. He was just kind of skulking all over the castle all angsty and I don't know, it was just really amusing). The part where Harry is on the Felix whatever was absolutely hilarious. I'm glad I saw the movie, in any case.
I'm so sleepy now. I got home around 3:30 AM but I had had a coffee and waaaayyyy too much candy before/during the movie, so it took me until past 4 AM to fall asleep, and then my mom decided it'd be a good idea to wake me up at 9 AM. And after I've woken up I can't get back to sleep again, and I can't take naps during the day or else I can't sleep at night, so I'm pretty much just a zombie right now.
I'm surprised at the lack of Harry Potter enthusiasm on my flist! For some reason I remember there being loads when OotP came out. Was that just because people typically like Ootp more than HBP? Or because the last book was coming out right after the movie so people were all amped up about that, but now that the series is over people don't care as much?
Anyways, I think I might reread the series now. The last time I did a read-through was right before DH came out, and I've only read that one once (and HBP only twice), so it seems like it's time.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2009-07-15 10:06 pm (UTC)I'm going to see it on friday... I can't wait!
no subject
Date: 2009-07-15 10:08 pm (UTC)I'm too busy to go see HP; so I've avoided talking about it.
& I srsly need to read the books.
no subject
Date: 2009-07-16 02:11 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-07-16 05:41 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-07-16 05:45 am (UTC)Have you not read the books at all, or do you mean reread?
no subject
Date: 2009-07-16 05:47 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2009-07-16 09:32 pm (UTC)how are you, btw?
no subject
Date: 2009-07-18 06:09 am (UTC)I'm good! Not really doing much, but it's nice to relax for once. How are you? Are you in Boston over the summer?
no subject
Date: 2009-07-18 03:59 pm (UTC)yep, studying for mcats and doing labwork. it's actually pretty quiet here over the summer; i expected it to be a lot busier from what other people have told me.
i watched two episodes of queer as folk on tv the other day. they still have reruns of it, aw.
no subject
Date: 2009-07-19 06:56 am (UTC)Ah, that's cool. I should probably be doing more so I have some chance of getting a job or internship next summer, but... I've failed at that. Oh well.
Aw, that's awesome. I haven't watched QAF in so long. I think I did a full series rewatch either the year before or after senior year in high school. That show is so much love. I'm actually going through Buffy now with my parents since I finally showed them it and they really like it. I'm in early season 3 now and it's so much fun watching it again. It's been ages since I've watch any of them.
no subject
Date: 2009-07-20 04:58 pm (UTC)yeah i still bust out my qaf 308 and 510 every once in a while.
no subject
Date: 2009-07-23 08:40 pm (UTC)I would do that, but if I see one episode, then I'm going to want to watch them all, pretty much.